
Research view
Title: | Ethnic differences in the prevalence of catatonia among hospitalized psychiatric patients in Kuwait |
Author: | Mohamed Mustafaa, Rasha E. Bassimb, Marwa Abdel Meguidb, Marwa Sultanb and Mohamed Al Dardiryc |
Abstract: |
Several studies have suggested the presence of ethnic/
racial differences in psychiatric presentation and diagnosis
[1–5], prevalence of psychiatric disorders [6,7],
response to psychotropic medications [8], and mental
healthcare utilization [9]. Most of these studies have
been carried out in the USA comparing African Americans
with white psychiatric patients [2–5,7–8] and a few
studies have included Asians [1,10]and Latinos [1,6].
In the 20th century, catatonia was redefined as a
neuropsychiatric syndrome that is known to occur in
association with several mental disorders [11]. It presents
commonly in psychiatric patients in both acute and longterm
settings. Despite its common occurrence, catatonia
remains a poorly understood, poorly studied, and poorly
recognized syndrome, presenting with a variety of
psychiatric and medical illnesses, which can be treated
once a diagnosis is established [12]. It is most commonly
characterized by mutism, stupor, refusal to eat or drink,
posturing, and excitement or hypokinesis [13].
Although catatonia is associated with schizophrenia and
had been deemed to be a subtype of it throughout the
20th century, it is most often caused by affective disorders
and medical or neurological illness, leading to its nature and
classification being reconsidered [14]. Moreover, being
reported to be commonly presented in different cultures in
different ways [15,16] implies that culture and ethnicity may influence how catatonia manifests in relation to
different psychiatric disorders [11].
A study carried out in Camberwell, London, comparing
white with Afrocaribbean schizophrenic patients regarding
their symptom profile, revealed that the latter group
showed more catatonic symptoms [17]. An earlier study of
the psychiatric morbidity among university students in
Egypt showed a high prevalence of paranoid and catatonic
symptoms [18]. Also, in another review on the prevalence
of mental illnesses in Egypt, Okasha et al. [19] reported
that catatonic forms of schizophrenia are relatively common
compared with other varieties. In contrast, a study on the
psychopathology of schizophrenia in a Kuwaiti sample
showed that catatonic symptoms were rare (2.9%),
compared with other symptoms of the disorder [20].
Furthermore, when 104 consecutively admitted patients in
Wales and India were screened for catatonic features using
the same standardized rating instrument, and by the same
psychiatrist, differences were seen in both prevalence and
symptoms, although not in severity [15].
Although the reasons for ethnic differences in psychiatric
diagnosis are unclear, several hypotheses have been
proposed, including the existence of actual ethnic
differences in the rates of psychiatric disorders, clinical
presentation, and clinician biases. Research regarding
these issues is scarce in the Arabian Gulf region, which
has been recently characterized by the presence of
multiple racial and ethnic minorities.
In the state of Kuwait, as in most other Gulf Cooperation
Council countries, the number of expatriates exceeds
that of national citizens. South Asians and Arabs form the largest segment of non-Kuwaiti population living in
Kuwait [21]. Over the last few years, however, the
number of black Africans, especially Ethiopians, has been
increasing. The presence of these different ethnic groups
and the presence of only one inpatient psychiatric service
in Kuwait have contributed to the need for carrying out
this study. Therefore, the objectives of this study were to
compare the prevalence and study the ethnic differences
of catatonic symptoms in different ethnic groups of
hospitalized psychiatric patients in Kuwait.
|
Journal: | Middle East Current Psychiatry 2012, 19:214–221 |
Text: | |
download |