
Research view
Title: | The role of personality profile in the motivation to quit smoking |
Author: | Zeinab Bishry, Mohamed Fekry, Heba El Shahawy, Marwa Soltan, Amany Haroun and Dalia Abdel Moneim |
Abstract: |
Tobacco is currently used by 1.3 billion individuals, of
whom 80% live in developing and transitional economy
countries. Tobacco is currently the second major cause of
death worldwide, being responsible for the deaths of one
in 10 adults worldwide, five million deaths each year. It is
the fourth most common risk factor for disease worldwide.
If the current smoking patterns continue, 10 million
tobacco-related deaths per year will occur by 2020. Of the
roughly 650 million individuals who are smoking today,
about half will eventually die due smoking complications
[1]. The economic costs of tobacco use include
the high public health costs of treating tobacco-caused
diseases, depriving families of breadwinners and nations of
a healthy workforce as tobacco kills individuals at the
height of their productivity and lowers productivity while
tobacco users are alive, because of increased sickness [2].
The intensity, duration, and pattern of nicotine abstinence
effects can vary widely across individuals [3].
Indeed, studies have identified several predictors of the
severity and quality of abstinence effects [4], including
psychiatric conditions [5], alcohol problems [6], and
sex [7]. It is important to identity the predictors of
abstinence effects because interventions can be selected
on the basis of a patient’s characteristics. For example,
Pomerleaue et al. [5] reported that depressed smokers are
at an increased risk of experiencing depressed mood
during nicotine abstinence and may therefore require
mood management interventions to buffer these effects
before a quit attempt [8].
Personality is also a significant clinical characteristic that
influences smoking patterns and may impact expressions
of nicotine withdrawal [9]. Several different theories and
measures of personality have been used in the smoking
literature, including Eysenck’s personality scales [10],
Zuckerman’s sensation seeking scale [11], Barratt’s
impulsivity scale [12], and Costa and McCrae’s NEO –
five-factor inventory) [9]. These measures are designed
to identify psychometrically supported affective and
behavioral patterns in humans. In contrast, Cloninger’s
psychobiological model of personality [13] is unique
because it is based on a synthesis of information from
twin and family studies, investigations of longitudinal development, neuropharmacological and neurobehavioral
studies of learning in humans and other animals, and
psychometric analyses of personality in individual and
twin pairs [14]. This model identifies personality
dimensions that may be manifestations of genetically
transmitted neuropharmacological processes [15–17].
These personality dimensions can be assessed by the
temperament and character inventory (TCI) [18]. The
factorial structures of temperament dimensions of
the TCI have been supported in several studies [13,19].
The heritability of the TCI’s temperament dimensions
has been supported by a large twin study that reported
heritability rates between 50 and 65% [20]. Nevertheless,
there remains some debate about the pharmacogenetic
and psychometric specificity of these dimensions [21].
Cloninger’s theory is especially relevant to smoking for
several reasons. First, the behaviors assessed in TCI
dimensions (e.g. impulsivity, intolerance of uncertainty)
are conceptually relevant to the initiation and maintenance
of nicotine dependence. For example, impulsive
individuals high in novelty seeking (NS) may become
more frustrated when restricted from nicotine reward and
therefore may experience greater negative affect during
tobacco abstinence. Second, the TCI measures heritable
traits that may mediate relations between genotypes and
smoking behavior [22]. For example, Elovainio et al. [22]
reported that the effect of the dopamine D4 receptor
genotype on smoking behavior was mediated by NS.
Third, systems involved in processing and responding to
appetitive, aversive, and novel stimuli that are related to
TCI temperament dimensions may also underlie smoking
behavior [23]. Specifically, responding to aversive stimuli,
such as the physical sensations of nicotine withdrawal,
may be exaggerated in individuals with particular TCI
profiles. Fourth, the pharmacological correlates of TCI
dimensions may be related to the pathophysiology of
nicotine addiction [24]. Indeed, dopaminergic and
serotonergic systems, which are related to NS and harm
avoidance (HA), have been implicated in nicotine withdrawal
[24].
There has been a considerable degree of research on the
association between TCI dimensions and smoking. Many
studies have reported that NS is associated with various
components of smoking behavior, including tobacco-use
initiation, smoking status, and the severity of nicotine
dependence [20,22,25–30]. HA and reward dependence
(RD) have been reported to be modestly associated with
smoking initiation and the severity of nicotine dependence
in some studies [20,25,30–32]. However, in other
studies, RD has been reported to be associated negatively
with tobacco dependence [30]. Given that there is a link
between temperament scores on the TCI and various
smoking characteristics, it is possible that smokers with
different temperaments may show different patterns of
acute tobacco withdrawal.
From the well-known relationship between smoking and
personality, the main objective of this study was to test
the association of personality profile and motivation to
quit smoking. In addition, this study aimed to compare
between those who were motivated to quit but could not
maintain the abstinence (relapsed motivated group) and
those who were able to maintain the abstinence
(nonrelapsed motivated group).
|
Journal: | Middle East Current Psychiatry 2012, 19:206–213 |
Text: | |
download |