
Research view
Title: | Polysomnographic assessment of patients with somatoform disorder in comparison with patients with major depressive disorder: a study in an Egyptian sample |
Author: | Mohamed Elwanb, Nabil Rashedc, Lamiaa El Hamrawyc, Mohamed Fekrya, Tarek Asaada and Amr Shalabyc |
Abstract: |
Somatoform ‘somatization’ disorder is a widespread
phenomenon across different cultures and healthcare
systems. In patients with somatoform disorders (SD),
emotional distress or difficult life situations are experienced
as physical symptoms [1].
Individuals with somatization perceive themselves as sick
and physically disabled [2]. The help-seeking behavior of
persons with somatization symptoms may be difficult for
physicians to understand [2,3]. Failure to identify this
condition and to manage it properly may lead to
frustrating, costly, and potentially dangerous interventions
that generally fail to identify occult disease and do
not reduce suffering [1].
Patients with unexplainable somatic symptoms usually have
a disturbed sleep pattern [4]. Plante et al. [5] reported that
the current formulation of SDs within psychiatry is limited
because it does not acknowledge the central role of sleep
disturbance that is common for all of these disorders.
What is the cause of sleep disturbance in patients with
SD? Is it related to associated anxiety symptoms or
depressive symptoms or both, or is it the result of
alexithymia usually found in such patients? Can pain also
be a factor? Is sleep disturbance genuine for patients with
SD? Or are all of the above factors relevant for patients
with SD? In this research, we attempt to answer these
questions by exploring the sleep profile of patients with
SD.
In this research, we chose to compare the sleep profile of
somatization patients with that of major depressive
disorder (MDD) patients, because of the following
reasons. Sleep in depression has been investigated in
more detail than that for any other psychiatric disorder,
although no findings have not been pathogonomic [6].
Somatization is a frequently mentioned feature of
depression in patients seen by primary care physicians [7],
and patients with somatization usually present with some
depressive features and sometimes develop full-blown
picture of MDDs. Finally alexithymia is a commonconstruct usually encountered in both disorders, with
some evidence that it has an effect on the sleep profile of
patients [8].
In terms of the sleep profile of MDD patients,
approximately two-thirds of patients with MDD have
some type of insomnia; of these, nearly 40% complain of
specific symptoms with sleep onset difficulty, frequent
awakenings, and early morning insomnia [9]. The
insomnia complaints of patients with depression can be
more severe than those of patients with primary insomnia
(i.e. insomnia related to behavioral and conditioning
factors). Approximately 15% of depressed patients
complain of hypersomnia [10].
The sleep profile of patients with depression has the
following characteristics: slow wave sleep (SWS) deficiency,
decreased sleep duration (caused by the increased
sleep latency, awakenings during the night, and early
morning awakenings), redistribution of rapid eye movement
(REM) sleep with its concentration in the first
half of the night, decreased REM sleep latency, increased
eye movement density in the first cycle, and absence
of the first night effect [6]. Although none of the abovementioned
alterations in the sleep profile is specific for
depression, their combination displays a pattern that is
mostly typical for depressed patients [11].
Previous researchers have attempted to find a biological link
between MDD and SD, for example, the study of Rief
et al. [12] aimed to examine possible immunological
differences between patients with major depression, somatization,
and healthy controls. Our research represents a
second step with the same aim, but uses a different
biological marker, which is the sleep profile of these patients
|
Journal: | Middle East Current Psychiatry 2012, 19:98–105 |
Text: | |
download |